Objectives
of the meeting
The objective of the meeting was to bring together major
stakeholders in the WNU process, including Founding Supporters,
academia and potential donors, to review the overall status
of WNU activities and their implementation, and to prepare
a WNU Action Plan including the preparation of first milestones.
Background
The World Nuclear University (WNU) was established in September
2003. The WNU network of partnership includes the four "Founding
Supporters" (WNA, WANO, IAEA, and OECD-NEA) and a worldwide
array of leadings institutions of nuclear education and
research. Full details on the WNU network may be found on
the WNU website at www.world-nuclear-university.org.
In the months following the inauguration, the WNU concept
was further developed on an international level. Discussions
involved all stakeholders, including Founding Supporters,
educational and research institutions participating in the
WNU network, potential corporate donors, and IAEA Member
States.
In June 2004, under the Agency's subprogramme C3 on Managing
Nuclear Knowledge the Agency, as a Founding Supporter, convened
a consultancy meeting to draft an Action Plan for WNU for
the period 2005-2006, and this Technical Meeting to address
the objective outlined above.
Work done
Mr. Y. Yanev opened the meeting and introduced the objectives
and Terms of Reference; Mr. A. Alonso, Spain, chaired the
meeting.
Mr. J. Ritch, DG WNA, presented the concept of WNU, the
steps leading to the WNU inauguration, and subsequent progress
including the results of discussions from the preceding
consultancy meeting on WNU on 8-9 June 2004. Building on
previous work, the consultancy had produced:
- A draft WNU Action Plan for 2005-2006;
- The draft concept of a WNU Summer Institute, beginning
in 2005.
Advantages of WNU
The meeting agreed on the advantages of WNU for four groups
of stakeholders: students, participating universities, industries
using nuclear technology, and governments/multinational
policy. These advantages are listed in Attachment 1.
WNU Action Plan for 2005-2006
The meeting discussed the present status of WNU, further
developed the draft WNU Action Plan that had been prepared
by the preceding consultancy meeting, and agreed that the
WNU Action Plan should now be implemented by all stakeholders,
including all of those with responsibilities for resource
support and operational participation.
The agreed WNU Action Plan, shown in Attachment 2, covers
the operation of the WNU in 2005-2006.
WNU Summer Institute in 2005
The meeting discussed and agreed on concept and content
of a WNU Summer Institute as first deliverable of WNU. The
concept of a WNU Summer Institute, to be held annually at
different locations, has been developed as:
- A special contribution to building future leadership
for the nuclear community;
- A valuable means of galvanizing cooperation within the
WNU network during the initial stages of the WNU partnership.
The meeting agreed on the following Mission Statement for
the WNU Summer Institute:
The purpose of the annual WNU Summer Institute is
to provide a unique educational experience aimed at building
future global leadership in the fields of nuclear science
and technology.
The Summer Institute will do so by providing, to a
select group of students and young professionals from
throughout the world, a period of intense high-quality
training designed to:
- Present cutting-edge knowledge and broad international
perspective on the full range of political, environmental
and social issues surrounding the peaceful application
of nuclear technology;
- Expose participants to the world's leading thinkers
and educators in topics relevant to nuclear applications;
- Enable participants to experience practical teamwork,
and to establish lasting bonds, with peers from many
nations;
- Inspire participants to commit themselves to advancing
the global contribution of nuclear science and technology.
The Summer Institute will serve both as a symbol and
as a substantively valuable manifestation of the ongoing
partnership established by the WNU among the world's leading
institutions of nuclear learning, technology development,
commerce, and policy governance.
The concept of the WNU Summer Institute is outlined in
Attachments 3, 4, and 5, which cover Participation, Timeline
for necessary preparation, and Courses to be delivered.
It was agreed that high-priority action should now be taken
by all relevant stakeholders to implement the concept of
the WNU Summer Institute.
Other expected deliverables of WNU
The WNU Working Groups will help to support the preparation
of the Summer Institute. Other projected deliverables of
WNU are listed in Attachment 6, including a major WNU Symposium
in fall of 2006 to present and review the results of all
of this cooperative activity.
Support mechanisms for WNU
Mr. Yanev presented the IAEA's position paper Agency's
Support to the World Nuclear University, which had been
developed through inter-departmental consultation following
the WNU inauguration. This summary of the Agency's WNU support
mechanisms is shown in Attachment 7. In addition, the Abdus
Salam International Centre for Theoretical Physics,
an important component of the UNESCO-IAEA family, will play
an important role in the WNU, particularly through training
and research involving physicists from developing countries.
It was understood by all meeting participants that implementation
of the WNU Action Plan will depend crucially on the prompt
contribution of necessary resources in the form of staff
secondments to the WNU and financial support. Mr. Ritch
emphasized that initial work in obtaining financial contributions
and commitments had been highly encouraging. Thus, the critical
component now remaining was the question of receiving high-quality
staff secondments from key participating institutions and
supporters.
In this regard, particular appreciation was expressed to
France and China, both having committed to second one highly
qualified staff contribution to the WNU HQ in London. Appreciation
was also expressed for the IAEA's support for the WNU, as
reflected in its hosting the meeting and its plans as reflected
in Attachment 7.
Results achieved
Through hosting the meeting, the Agency supported the WNU
process as outlined in the Agency's position paper on WNU.
Through the combination of this meeting and the preceding
consultancy on 8-9 June, considerable progress was achieved
in charting a path forward for implementing the WNU concept.
This progress is reflected in the WNU Action Plan for 2005-2006
contained herein.
Recommendations
The meeting agreed that all relevant stakeholders should
promptly take the full range of actions - and make the resource
contributions - necessary to implement the WNU Action Plan,
starting with the urgent steps needed to produce a first
WNU Summer Institute in 2005.
Attachment 1: Advantages for WNU Stakeholders
1. Students
- At Participating Universities
- Stronger curricula
- Scholarship support for nuclear education
- Enhanced qualifications for a global marketplace
- WNU Summer Institute Participants
- Participation in a unique world-class educational
experience
- Global networking with peers and high-level professionals
- Prestige and career advancement
2. Participating Universities
- Faculty opportunity for mobility and networking
- Prestige for nuclear department and university
- Funded world-class students (after creation of WNU Fellowship
Fund)
- Enriched curriculum
- Efficient sharing of R & D facilities
3. Industries Using Nuclear Technology
- Increased prestige of the industry and profession
- Direct influence on coursework development
- Larger and stronger recruitment pool (equipped with
"globalised" qualifications, teamwork experience
and critical thinking)
- Opportunity to identify top recruitment prospects
4. Governments and Multinational Policy
- Stronger national educational systems
- Enhanced recruitment pool for policy and regulatory
agencies
- A new generation of global "nuclear statesmen"
- Improved public perception of a technology critical
to policy objectives
- A strengthened global industry to achieve those objectives
Attachment 2: WNU Action Plan
1. Overall Objective
- Identify, integrate and implement advanced strategies
to enhance global education in nuclear science and engineering.
2. Near-Term Goals
- Initiate ongoing collaboration within the WNU network:
- Inter-institutional cooperation (in harmony with the
ENEN, ANENT, ERASMUS, EMNT) in the sharing of faculty,
students, facilities, coursework through distance-learning
- Identify and share best-practices in coursework and
curricula, and develop new coursework where needed
- Implement plan for unique future-leader-oriented WNU
Summer Institute
- Develop Industry Leadership Courses for nuclear CEO's,
CFO's and board members
- Pursue full results-oriented WNU agenda (see Attachment
VI)
- Events
- 2005 Summer Institute (leading students)
- 2006 Summer Institute (leading students)
- 2006 WNU Fall Symposium (culmination of 2 years of
WNU collaboration)
3. Longer-Term Goals
- Prepare and deliver Public Education programme
- Orientation Courses for government, commercial,
scientific, media leaders
- Public Presentation workshops for industry officials
- Establish WNU Fellowship Programme (philanthropic and
corporate support)
4. Necessary Resources
- Staff secondments
- Funding
Attachment 3: Annual WNU Summer Institute Participation
Qualification criteria:
- Master's level or equivalent experience in science or
engineering, with knowledge of nuclear fundamentals; demonstrated
academic or professional excellence
- Proficiency in English, particularly oral communication
- Maximum age of 30
Selection
- WNU will recruit applicants through the WNU network
(WNU Founding Supporters and participating WNU institutions);
applications to be submitted to London headquarters
- WNU Country Representatives will supervise national
selection process, using national perspective and institutions
to apply qualification criteria
- A WNU centralised selection committee makes final decision,
choosing approximately 60 participants, aiming to reach
a broad geographical distribution and a balance between
developed and developing countries
- Overall aim is a synergistic mix of leading students
and top young professionals already in the nuclear industry
- Funding support for students to come from various sources,
including the WNU budget, special corporate contributions,
and IAEA TC (as outlined in the IAEA's position paper
on WNU support)
Attachment 4: WNU Summer Institute Implementation Timeline
|
|
Jun
04
|
Jul
04
|
Aug
04
|
Sep
04
|
Oct
04
|
Nov
04
|
Dec
04
|
Jan
05
|
Feb
05
|
Mar
05
|
Apr
05
|
May
05
|
Jun
05
|
Jul
05
|
Aug
05
|
| Set
Curriculum |
x
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
| Confirm
Site |
x
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Activate
WG
Collaboration |
|
x
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Begin
Country
Selection Prep |
|
x
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
| Assure
Funding |
|
|
|
x
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Establish
Action Team |
|
|
|
x
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Issue
S.I.
Announcement |
|
|
|
x
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Select
Key
Faculty |
|
|
|
|
x
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Application
Deadline |
|
|
|
|
|
x
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
| Select
Students |
|
|
|
|
|
|
x
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Develop
S.I.
Programme |
|
x
|
x
|
x
|
x
|
x
|
x
|
x
|
x
|
x
|
x
|
x
|
x
|
|
|
Conduct
First
WNU S.I. |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
x
|
x
|
Attachment 5: WNU Summer Institute Courses
|
Activity
|
Sessions
|
| Instruction |
35
|
| Teamwork |
20
|
| Field
Trips, Special Activities |
5
|
| Total |
60
|
| Plus:
Evening Lectures and Events |
|
| Instruction
Content |
Sessions
(units)
|
Topic
|
| Global
Setting |
| |
1
|
Global
Energy Demand / Supply |
| |
2
|
Global
Climate / Environment / Sustainability |
| |
2
|
Non-Power
Applications |
| |
1
|
Developing
Country Presentations |
| International
Regimes |
| |
4
|
Safety
(Standards, Regimes, Risk Assessment, Roles of IAEA,
WANO, ICRP) |
| |
2
|
Radiological
Protection / Health / Public Debate / LNT & Other
Issues |
| |
3
|
Security
(Non-Proliferation, Physical Protection, Future Systems) |
| |
3
|
Waste Management & Decommissioning (Science / Politics
/ Plans) |
| |
1
|
Nuclear
Transport |
| |
2
|
Nuclear
Law |
| Nuclear
Industry |
| |
1
|
Nuclear
Excellence & Operational Focus |
| |
1
|
Comparative
Risk Assessment |
| |
2
|
Industry
Economics |
| |
2
|
Knowledge
Management (Nuclear Work Force Projections, Succession
Planning) |
| |
1
|
Technology
and Social Ethics |
| |
2
|
Public
Communication (Polling / Psychology / Risk Communication) |
| Innovation |
| |
2
|
Innovative
Nuclear Science & Technology (Gen-IV, INPRO, Advanced
Fuel Cycle, national programmes) |
| |
2
|
New
Technologies (Hydrogen, Desalination, Fusion, Health) |
| |
1
|
Global
Emissions Control (Potential Regimes) |
| Total |
35
|
|
Attachment 6: Innovative Collaboration within the WNU Partnership:
Projected Results
1) Knowledge Management
WNU Asset: Couple IAEA Programme to comprehensive WANO/WNA
membership
- Activate worldwide knowledge retention plan at nuclear
facilities
- Develop knowledge bases in various areas of nuclear
science & technology
- Identify recommendations on succession planning
- Devise institutional strategies for nuclear information
management
2) Global Nuclear Safety Culture
WNU Assets: Couple IAEA Materials to WNU University Network;
Use WANO-Identified Needs to Shape WNU Education & Training
- Collate IAEA Safety Materials for Assimilation into
WNU Network
- Devise safety education & training courses based
on WANO experience
- Create special orientation courses for industry leadership
3) Reactor and Isotope Research
WNU Assets: Combine with ENEN and ANENT to Foster Trans-Regional
Cooperation Among WNU Universities; Potential to Win Philanthropic
Support for WNU-Sponsored Research
- Catalogue research programmes at WNU Universities
- Identify potential research partnerships
- Foster facility sharing
- Develop strategy for attracting philanthropic support
for WNU-sponsored research
4) Nuclear Law
WNU Asset: Couple ISNL (Montpellier School) to WNU Network
- Identify needs in global nuclear law education
- Develop and implement plan for globalizing instruction
in nuclear law
5) Nuclear Safeguards and Security
WNU Assets: Couple Institutional assets of IAEA, INMM,
ESARDA, National Labs & Think Tanks to WNU Universities;
Draw on World-Class Expertise in Creative Context
- Identify and make available best-practice non-proliferation
courses
- Harmonise the work of non-proliferation institutions
- Support/complement the work of official IAEA activities
with non-official consideration of innovative security
concepts
6) Societies and Nuclear Technology
WNU Asset: Draw from Worldwide Experience to Develop
Best-Practices in Public Education
- Design WNU-branded materials in multiple languages for
school use
- Develop nuclear-orientation programmes for science teachers
- Establish WNU as a respected media-reference source
- Consider strategies for developing networks of influential
nuclear-knowledgeable individuals and groups
7) Prospects in the Nuclear Profession
WNU Asset: Potential to assemble a global needed assessment
- and deliver to a global audience of students - a comprehensive
assessment of career prospects in the nuclear profession
- Prepare a comprehensive assessment of the future global
use of nuclear power (building on studies by MIT/Harvard
and UK's Royal Institute) and non-power technologies (building
on national reports on the pervasive use of non-power
applications)
- Consider possible feedback mechanisms by which industry
can advise curriculum developers on anticipated industry
needs
- Develop - for the use of faculty and students - a concise
annual report outlining career prospects in the nuclear
profession
- Design a transnational strategy for overcoming projected
global shortfall in nuclear professionals
8) Special Projects
WNU Asset: Draw from Worldwide Expertise to Develop Unique
and Respected Concept Papers on Topics of Critical Global
Interest, with Substantial Value in Underpinning the Peaceful
Use of Nuclear Technology
- Develop practical concepts for introducing nuclear expertise
into all relevant international development agencies
- Devise the elements of a politically feasible global
emissions reduction regime that would adequately incentivize
a worldwide transformation to clean energy
Attachment 7: IAEA paper on Agency's Support to the
World Nuclear University
The World Nuclear University (WNU) was inaugurated on the
4th September 2003 with a mission to strengthen the international
community of people and institutions in their efforts to
further develop:
- The safe and increasing use of nuclear power as a proven
technology able to produce clean energy on a global scale;
and
- The many valuable applications of nuclear science and
technology that contribute to sustainable agriculture,
medicine, nutrition, industrial development, management
of fresh water resources and environmental protection.
Through a worldwide network of established institutions
of nuclear learning, the WNU will be seeking to promote
academic rigour and high professional ethics in all phases
of nuclear related activity. The WNU has been created as
a forward looking initiative, offering new forms of co-operation
for the world nuclear community and having as its main objective
the synergy of people and ideas.
The Agency has been supportive in assisting WNU, particularly
during the early formative stages, to define its mission
and focus thus avoiding duplication and preventing potential
rivalries and competition for the same resource. This paper
represents the common approach in supporting WNU as an Agency
wide knowledge management crosscutting activity*.
The overall objective in supporting the World Nuclear
University is to leverage the value of the Agency's programmatic,
training and educational activities by using WNU platform
as an additional vehicle and tool for implementation, especially
in cases where this offers better and more widely distributed
results and impacts.
As a start it has been agreed that it will be appropriate
for the Agency to:
- Cooperate with WNU in activities aimed at improving
the scope and quality of relevant nuclear science and
technology-related educational courses worldwide. One
particular aspect is course harmonization across the participating
universities.
- Offer students from developing countries access to good
quality education courses in WNU member universities through
dedicated fellowships, specific training courses, workshops
and summer schools.
- Promote the use of distance learning techniques for
nuclear education by providing WNU access to Agency training
material and participation in the development of new courses.
- Work with WNU on attracting attention and increasing
the number of students trained in nuclear science and
technology worldwide by implementing outreach activities,
facilitate networking in regions and involving students
in innovative projects, field activities, etc.
The following is an initial list of support actions**
that can be implemented in 2004 and 2005 that can be linked
to WNU:
I. Provision of high quality training and/or training
material to the member universities of WNU network:
- Department of NE - Training material and courses on
energy planning, reactor simulator training, radioactive
waste management; nuclear knowledge management; reactor
technology.
- Department of NS*** - Training material in Nuclear Safety,
Radiation Protection, Waste Safety, Nuclear Security,
- Department of NA - Training material and courses on
nuclear non power technology and application, nuclear
medicine, nuclear techniques in agriculture,
- Department of TC - relevant courses and other training
materials for activities supported by TC wherever it is
considered appropriate to involve WNU,
- Department of SG/EXPO - Contributions to courses/course
modules on the safeguards system of the IAEA and its role
in the nuclear non-proliferation regime
- Department MT/OLA - Training on Elements of Nuclear
Law.
II. TC-supported fellowships at University Networks
of WNU: A number of TC-sponsored fellowships could be
implemented in WNU member universities where the Agency
has an existing programmatic activity within on-going TC
programme, or when there are specific requests from recipient
Member States to support such fellowships. Three universities
- Russia -MEPhI, Italy-University of Pavia, Argentina -
University of Buenos Aires - would meet this option at present.
All of them are working with the Agency and are also founding
members of WNU. In addition, WNU would be strongly encouraged
to fund additional relevant fellowships through its network
and contributors.
III. Facilitated access to INIS and the Agency's Library
nuclear information resources, made available to WNU
students. This may involve (subject to resource allocation)
some short visits and training in Nuclear Information Management
at IAEA headquarters for students of WNU.
IV. Inviting WNU to relevant Agency meetings and providing
Agency facilities as a focal point/venue for WNU meetings,
V. Providing lecturers, where appropriate (see I)
and especially for key training events (such as major summer
school and workshops of WNU).
* Within the Agency the interaction and support to WNU should
be coordinated through a single focal point.
** The IAEA's recognition in all of the above activities
is necessary as it underpins our assistance to Member States.
*** Use of all IAEA training material by WNU is unrestricted,
however whenever used proper reference should be made to
the IAEA.
Attachment 8: List of participants at the Technical Meeting
| |
Name
(Participant/Nominated)
|
Organization
|
Country
|
| 1 |
Mr.
Zuoyi Zhang |
Institute
of Nuclear Energy Technology, Tsinghua University |
China
|
| 2 |
H.E.
Mr. Raimundo González Aninat |
Representante
Permanente de Chile ante el OIEA |
Chile
|
| 3 |
Mr.
Roberto Ebert G. |
Alterno
Representante Permanente de Chile ante el OIEA |
Chile
|
| 4 |
Mr.
Julio Vergara A. |
Chilean
Nuclear Energy Commission |
Chile
|
| 5 |
Mr.
Ravi Bhushan Grover |
Bhabha
Atomic Research Centre |
India
|
| 6 |
Ms
Fatimah Mohd Amin |
Research
Management Centre Malaysian Institute for Nuclear Technology
Research |
Malaysia
|
| 7 |
Mr.
Augustin Alonso |
Universidad
Politécnica de Madrid |
Spain
|
| 8 |
Mr.
Jean-Louis Nigon |
COGEMA |
France
|
| 9 |
Mr.
Richard Clegg |
Manchester
University |
UK
|
| 10 |
Mr.
Alan E.Waltar |
Pacific
Northwest National Lab. |
USA
|
| 11 |
Mr. Gilbert J. Brown |
University
of Massachusetts Lowell |
USA
|
| 12 |
Mr.
Anselm Schaefer |
Institute
for Safety and Reliability GmbH |
Germany
|
| 13 |
Ms.
Keiko Hanamitsu |
Japan
Atomic Industrial Forum, Inc. |
Japan
|
| 14 |
Mr.
Antonio Faucitano |
University
of Pavia |
Italy
|
| 15 |
Mr.
B. N. Onykiy |
Moscow
Engineering Physics Institute (State University) |
Russia
|
| 16 |
Mr.
Eduard Kryuchkov |
Moscow
Engineering Physics Institute (State University) |
Russia
|
| 17 |
Mr.
Peter Paul De Regge |
European
Nuclear Education Network |
ENEN
|
| 18 |
Mr.
Sig Berg |
World
Association of Nuclear Operators |
WANO
|
| 19 |
Mr.
Patrick Reyners |
Organisation
for Economic Co-Operation and Development/ Nuclear Energy
Agency |
OECD/NEA
|
| 20 |
Mr.
Claudio Tuniz |
The
Abdus Salam International Centre for Theoretical Physics |
ICTP
|
| 21 |
Mr.
John B Ritch |
World
Nuclear University and World Nuclear Association |
WNU
and WNA
|
| 22 |
Mr.
Yanko Yanev |
IAEA
(NE) |
IAEA
|
| 23 |
Mr.
Peter Gowin |
IAEA
(NE) |
IAEA
|
| 24 |
Mr. H.H. Rogner |
IAEA
(NA) |
IAEA
|
| 25 |
Mr.
Piero Danesi |
IAEA
(NA) |
IAEA
|
|